The Blue Stone

Returning to the mountain where my son died, and finding life still asking for me

This essay is part of the Between Chapters project, inspired by the book. What chapters are you between? How did you get from one chapter to another? Share your story here.

---

What Chapter Are You…

In:

Parenting the living while loving the dead.

---

I had imagined the moment dozens of times.

Five years after our nine-year-old son, William, died in a ski accident at Big Sky, my family was finally returning to the mountain. I pictured us standing quietly at the place where he took his last breath. We’d hold hands. We’d cry. I’d breathe in the same mountain air he had breathed, hoping somehow to feel close to him again.

Instead, my three-year-old screamed at me because I threw a blue rock into the trees.

For a split second, I wanted to rewind the moment. This wasn’t how it was supposed to happen. This was sacred ground. This was where my son died.

But grief has never cared much about my plans.

William died when he was nine years old. In the years that followed, Big Sky stopped being just a ski resort. It became the place that divided my life into before and after. It held our worst day, our deepest sorrow, and every unanswered question I knew would never be answered.

Still, after five years, it was time to go back.

We brought our boys with us: Kai, who remembers his older brother vividly, and Bodhi, who was born after William died. Bodhi has never met William, but he knows him. We say his name often. We tell stories about him. He has always been part of our family.

That morning felt strangely peaceful. We grabbed coffee and croissants, packed snacks for Bodhi, and headed to the base of the mountain. Waiting there were the first responders who had been there the day William died.

Photo by Giorgia Finazzi on Unsplash

The last time we had seen one another, our lives had intersected in unimaginable tragedy. This time, there were hugs, introductions, and smiles. It was unexpectedly healing to meet them in this place, not at the worst moment of our lives, but years later, standing together in the light.

Then we began the hike.

Without snow, the mountain looked unfamiliar. The chairlifts stood still overhead, and the rocky trail wound quietly up the hill.

Almost immediately, I realized how close we were.

So close to the base.

So close to the lifts.

So close to where I had been waiting for William that day.

It would have taken only three minutes to ski down.

Three minutes from safety.

Three minutes from everything being okay.

That’s all it takes sometimes. Minutes.

My husband stopped walking.

For years, he had believed he was far away when another skier told him that a boy had gone off the trail. Standing there now, he realized he had actually been only a few feet from William.

Then we saw the tree.

It wasn’t towering or dramatic. It was small. Thin. So thin that an orange rope had been tied around it so we could distinguish it from the others.

I couldn’t stop staring at it.

How could something so small take something so big?

I hadn’t come looking for answers. There are no answers that can make the death of a child acceptable.

I came because I wanted to stand where William had stood. To breathe the air he breathed. To feel, if only for a moment, close to him.

We walked to the tree together.

We held hands.

We cried.

Kai collapsed into my arms, apologizing over and over, as though somehow he carried responsibility for losing his brother. I held him tightly and thought, This is it. This is the moment I’ve been preparing for.

Then Bodhi tugged at my hand.

“Where’s William?”

The question stopped all of us.

Over the years, we had always told Bodhi that William died in the trees. Somewhere along the way, our language had softened. We would point toward the woods and tell him that’s where William was. What we meant was memory. What we meant was spirit. What we meant was that this was where we felt closest to him.

But three-year-olds don’t speak metaphor.

They take you at your word.

Bodhi thought William was actually in the trees.

He thought we were finally going to find his brother.

My heart sank.

Oh my God, I thought. What have we done?

I had brought three worry stones with me that day. Years earlier, I had given them to William on his first day of third grade so he wouldn’t feel scared at school. Ever since he died, I had carried them in my purse.

I wanted to leave them for him.

There was a green stone, a pink stone, and a blue stone.

Kai chose the green one, William’s favorite color.

Bodhi surprised me by choosing the pink one, even though blue had always been his favorite.

That left the blue stone in my hand.

Photo by Maria Nikolova on Unsplash

I threw it into the trees.

And Bodhi exploded.

He screamed.

He cried.

He demanded that I go get it back.

He was convinced I had been saving the blue stone for him.

“You’re mean!” he yelled. “Go get it!”

He had never spoken to me like that before.

There I was, standing at the place where my son died, holding another child whose world had suddenly come undone.

It was everything I hadn’t imagined.

I had expected reverence. Instead, I was parenting.

And in that moment, something shifted inside me.

I realized I hadn’t come back only to honor the child I had lost.

I had come back to care for the children still standing beside me.

Grief doesn’t pause life.

Life barges in.

Sometimes loudly. Sometimes inconveniently. Sometimes as a three-year-old who believes his brother is waiting in the trees and cannot understand why his mother just threw away the wrong rock.

For years, I thought healing meant returning to the place where William took his last breath.

Instead, healing found me in the interruption.

It found me in comforting my living child while carrying the love I still have for the one who died.

The mountain gave me something I didn’t know I needed.

Not closure.

Not answers.

A reminder.

The work of motherhood didn’t end when William died.

It expanded.

Now it asks me to do two things at once: to honor the son I will always miss while showing up, fully present, for the children who still reach for my hand.

---

Follow Susie Shaw on Substack and Instagram.